Not a Hope in Prayer

Well all need hope, this is common sense. Hope can come from many things. For some, hope comes from prayer and it is easy to see why if we follow the logic of those who use prayer:

God exists and cares for his creation -> God can hear me if I pray-> Therefore, if I pray God may help me.

There are other reasons for praying such as gratitude and worship but the most hope comes from  the kind of prayer that believes God can and does help worshipers. Of course this logic makes a lot of assumptions:

  1. God exists: A pretty big assumption. This is a belief that defies logic.
  2. God cares: Even if God does exist given the suffering in the world it is hard to believe that God cares much for us.
  3. If I pray God may help me: A belief only supported by anecdotal evidence that both the teller and receiver accept at face value.

There is no evidence that prayer works at all. The scientific community has looked at the subject and all reached the same conclusion:

American Heart Journal: ‘Intercessory prayer itself had no effect on complication-free recovery from CABG, but certainty of receiving intercessory prayer was associated with a higher incidence of complications.’
Harvard: Prayer Not Effective In Reducing Complications Following Heart Surgery
Mayo Clinic:  ‘As delivered in this study, intercessory prayer had no significant effect on medical outcomes after hospitalization in a coronary care unit.’

What these studies proved is not just that prayer is ineffective but should never be a replacement for professional medical care. Providing people with false hopes is always dangerous.

So where is the hope?

In you, that’s where. It sounds cliche but all the power of hope comes from within you. It comes from a fundamental belief that you can make it through whatever challenges may come your way (optimism) and if you don’t a little acceptance that you are only human goes a long way. There are many  worldly sources of hope that deserve appreciation such as:

Art: Painting, sculpture, music and culture. A visit to a natural/cultural museum always restores my faith in humanity. A faith, I might add, that was just reinforced with tangible evidence.

Friends and family: This is also common sense. Religious fundamentalist often say that unbelievers can’t have real family love. The truth is we often value it much more because of the simple realization that they are all we’ve got. Seriously, who can’t look at their child’s smile and not have all the hope they need?

Life Itself: Nature in all its glory is an amazing thing. A single leaf on a tree has thousands, possibly millions of cells (themselves sophisticated and incredible). It is capable of changing sunlight and water into energy for the tree it is attached to. there are hundreds and maybe thousands of these on a single tree. As long as we are alive we are able take deep breaths of clean air, enjoy great foods, great fun and great company. Life is is full of wonder, hope and amazement if you want it to be. For those that it is not we can take hope is trying to help them restore theirs.

Wherever your hope comes from it is just fundamentally more powerful and proactive to take it from within life itself. By doing this we begin to better appreciate and respect our life and the life of other people. Imagine if  fundamentalists worshiped life as much as they do God how much better off we all would be.


3 thoughts on “Not a Hope in Prayer

Add yours

  1. While it may be a large assumption that God exists, it is even a larger assumption that we exist without God. Everything that is, including you and me, was made by Him out of nothing. He can take the nothing that I am and make something really great. He is our great, awesome, creator God. And He is sovereign. I say this in love. Please consider. – Frank
    Proverbs 3:5,6; Acts 4:12; Psalm 1; Psalm 14:1.


    1. But, where did he come from? How was he created? He couldn’t have just come out of nothing…. And if you say that “He has always been there,” why can’t you say the universe has always been here? Whatever your justification for his existence…why don’t you apply it to the universe? If it made sense for god, it should make sense for the universe.


  2. @ Frank: “it is even a larger assumption that we exist without God”
    Sorry bud, but no. We have explanations for how we got here that don’t need a god. Until you can offer positive evidence for the existence of ANY god, belief in said god is always the larger assumption.

    As to the post, I understand where you are coming from in terms of finding hope. I have a great deal of ‘faith’ in humanity. I wish I were able to share it with others more easily.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: